Because traumatic brain injuries are the result of a trauma, it’s common for TBI survivors to also suffer from PTSD. But differentiating the cause of symptoms can be challenging. Depression, anxiety, cognitive difficulties, and fatigue are common to both. But PTSD is a mental condition, whereas TBI is a neurological condition.

In TBIs, individuals may experience retrograde amnesia: memory loss of events – usually recent ones – that occurred prior to the injury. Before the elderly driver ran into me at the Santa Monica Farmers’ Market, I recall holding a peach, then nothing else, until I woke up in the emergency room more than an hour later. Even then, my memory is spotty. In PTSD, people are haunted by intrusive thoughts and memories of the trauma. Even though I do not remember the accident, I have been haunted by thoughts of the gruesome scene. Imagination is powerful.

Fatigue is a hallmark feature of TBIs. The brain tires easily, and therefore must work harder to process information. When I’m exposed to too much stimuli – chatter, whining children, and bright lights – I feel as if my head is stuffed with cotton. In PTSD, hyper-vigilance keeps people awake (see Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder: A Re-Wired Brain). In anticipation of nightmares, they may be afraid to fall asleep. So my TBI causes my brain to work over-time, and the nightmares I still experience startle me awake, keep me awake, draining what little fuel is remaining in my brain.

In TBIs, there may be damage to the frontal lobe – the area of the brain that controls emotions and personality, so emotional swings are not uncommon. In the few years after my injury, I found that I was more irritable and cried for no apparent reason: when washing the dishes, or standing in line at the bank. Emotional numbness is more common in PTSD. People may no longer be interested activities they once enjoyed. I recall days when it took a Herculean effort just to get out of bed and dressed for the day – sometimes it still does.

About fifty percent of those with TBIs suffer from depression. Compare that to the approximately seven percent among the general adult population. Depression is also common in those with PTSD, particularly war veterans, but since they want to avoid the stigma of mental illness, they hesitate to report symptoms and refrain from talking about the trauma at all.

Since PTSD is an anxiety disorder it’s natural for people to experience heightened stress, especially when reminded of the trauma. But in TBIs, people appear unmotivated when the truth is they lack the ability to initiate activities. I may seem lazy because I don’t cook and rarely food shop, but that’s because my TBI presents with the inability to make decisions – which kind of pasta to buy, or what to cook for dinner.

Given the overlapping of symptoms between a TBI and PTSD, neither one fits squarely on its own shelf. But I suppose that’s the way it goes with most things.

http://www.nimh.nih.gov/health/publications/the-numbers-count-mental-disorders-in-america/index.shtml

http://www.brainlinemilitary.org/content/2013/03/tbi-and-ptsd-navigating-the-perfect-storm_pageall.html

Traumatic Brain Injuries 101 In the United States, 52,000 deaths occur each year from a traumatic brain injury (TBI), and 5.3 million people live with disabilities due to a TBI. But a TBI does not necessarily result from a major trauma, like skiing into a tree or plummeting off a roof. You can sustain a TBI from bumping your head on a kitchen cabinet door, or when you and your five year old smack foreheads while wrestling. Penetrating injuries – from a bullet, or other objects that enter the skull – can also cause TBI’s. But the most common causes are from auto accidents and falls.

TBIs range from mild to severe. Mild injuries – concussions – are the most common. Symptoms include confusion, irritability, nausea, fatigue, amnesia around the event, and loss of consciousness up to 30 minutes. But it’s possible to suffer a mild TBI and not lose consciousness. Also, being diagnosed with a mild TBI does not mean the consequences are mild, such as decreased concentration and attention, getting lost and confused, headaches, dizziness, depression, mood swings, sleep disturbances, and difficulty with balance. Many people experience these symptoms for years, which is what happened to me. I still suffer from poor concentration, depression, difficulty multi-tasking, planning and even judging distance. When driving, for instance, I have trouble thinking ahead (at least that’s what my husband tells me). But it’s true. My brain can’t process all the stimuli coming at me: other cars, beeping horns, bicycles, and joggers. It doesn’t have enough room to focus on getting in the left lane soon enough so I can take a left turn.

In moderate TBI’s, the individual loses consciousness from 30 minutes to 24 hours, and in severe TBIs, longer than 24 hours. Symptoms are worse for people diagnosed with moderate to severe TBIs. They tend to exhibit obvious behavioral issues like aggression, and suffer greater physical impairments, like decreased ability to smell (anosmia), ringing in the ears (tinnitus), paralysis, and slurred speech.

But the challenge is in diagnosing TBIs, especially mild ones (like I said earlier, mild from a trauma perspective, not from a consequence perspective. I’ll address the nuances of this in a future post). My TBI was diagnosed in 2006, three years after I sustained the injury. During the immediate hours after the accident, the doctors where concerned with my other injuries – stopping the bleeding from my ruptured spleen and stabilizing my fractured pelvis. So I struggled in the workplace for two years, and at home, blaming my symptoms wholly on PTSD.

http://www.northeastern.edu/nutraumaticbraininjury/consequences-of-tbi/